Barry Beracha:
“Creating Value through Spin-Offs” delivered at UM-St.
Louis
transcribed by Liz Shahnam
1. Values of Earthgrains
- Willingness to change, adapt and be flexible
- Young, still establishing identity
- Proactive
- Growth centered around technology and science
2. Spin-off Phenomenon
Wall Street has recognized the affinity for spin-offs it as a
phenomenon. Why wouldn’t AB hold onto Earthgrains and get the value?
Because Earthgrains as a business is very different from that of AB, and
is best handled as its own company. (Peter Lynch has described the late-80’s
phenomenon of acquiring unrelated businesses not as diversification but
rather as diworsification.”) We note that there is market value
created through spin-offs, as is evidenced by the fact that in 1990-96
$190 billion created through spin-offs
Local examples of spin-offs include Emerson, May Company, Monsanto
(Solutia). Therefore spin-offs are a key factor in creating value
The spin-off momentum opposes the diversification trend of the 1980’s
(Earthgrains provides stability, growth, reduced risk through business
cycles). The 1990’s is the era of strategic focus on core competency
and critical mass. Conglomerates are de-coupling focusing on a “pure
play” company from an investor perspective.
4. Why spin-off?
- Future value must be greater than current market value
- Both parent and spin company benefit
- Tax efficient as many spin transactions are not taxable events
- Increased shareholder value
We note that Wall Street shows that spins outperform the market in
general by 30% over its first 3-4 years.
5. Principals of value creation:
- Vision-strategy
- Focus on strategic offerings: measurable, tracked and accountability
- Flexibility to adapt to changes in market place and opportunities
- Rewards that motivate management and workforce.
6. Earthgrains History
- Acquired in 1982 (formerly known as Campbell-Taggert)
- July 1995 AB announced spin-off
- 3/27/96 spin completed
7. Why Spin Earthgrains?
- Strategic fit (or lack thereof)
- EG has distinct financial, investment and operating characteristics
from those of AB
- The exigencies of the baking industry are better met as an
independent company
- Potential value of the company is greater as a spin
- Baking industry challenges:
- Focus o volume instead of margin
- Lack of pricing discipline
- Local economies of scale
- Slow pace of technology innovation
- Few industrial player publicly held
- No strong industry leader
Prior to the spin, the baking industry was not followed by Wall Street.
8. Earthgrains Strategy
- increase revenues and margins
- offer quality, value, and variety of products to consumers
- enhance customer satisfaction
- reduce and control costs
- participate in industry consolidation trend
Revenues in 1996 are $1.663 million, with 78% domestic, some
international. EG is the 2nd largest US refrigerated dough manufacturer in
the U.S. In MO it’s #2. #1 bagel in MO
Refrigerated dough produces private label refrigerated dough and toaster
pastries in two plants. There is national distribution and quality meets
or exceeds the competition (primarily Pillsbury).
International operations
- Bimbo: largest commercial baker in Spain. 8 bakeries in Spain and
Canary Islands
- Europe: only producer of canned dough in Europe
9. Stock performance:
- S&P500 up 47%
- BUD up 37%
- EG up 180% (Recognized as a turnaround, with its 6th consecutive
quarter of increasing earnings)
- Also, baking industry showing improved fundamentals
10. Value Creation
Use focus, flexibility, rewards (to apply to all businesses)
Focus
- business strategy understood throughout company
- objectives aligned with accountability
- measurements in place
It’s the most important driver of value creation. We note that we
are implementing SAP’s integrated manufacturing as a means of using
technology to enhance business processes.
Flexibility
- management decision-making
- response to market conditions
- seize opportunities
Flexibility is indicated by:
- Strong balance sheet (modest debt level)
- Ability to take advantage of industry consolidation
- Major acquisition pending before FTC
- R&D/new products
- Acquired Heiner’s Baker
Rewards
- Retain/motivate workforce
- Link behavior to strategy and goals
- Push rewards down (401K, employee purchase plan, stock options)
- Direct relationship to company performance
- Tied to profitability focal points and stock price performance
Summary
- spin-offs are win-win
- spin-offs can create value
- Value created through
- Vision-strategy
- Focus
- Flexibility
- Rewards
- Principals apply to all businesses
.