Week 6: Anthropology 11--Introduction to Cultural Anthropology

Lecture Notes for Chapter 4:

Language and Communication  (90-117)

basketweave line

 

Professor John Wolford
Department of Anthropology
University of Missouri-St. Louis

Email: wolfordj@msx.umsl.edu



 
Definitions for Chapter 4 Outline for Chapter 4 Anthro 11 homepage GO TO BOTTOM OF THE PAGE

Links to outside web pages: [Wolford's A11 Web Page] [My Gateway Page] [Reserves Page]



The important questions Haviland cites for you to consider while reading this chapter:
 

What is language?

How is language related to culture?

How did language begin?
 


Notes for William A. Haviland, 

Cultural Anthropology, 10th edition: 

Chapter 4:  Language and Communication  (90-117)

Return to Top

Culture is the medium of survival for people

Because culture is learned, it must have an efficient means of transmission
 

• language satisfies that need, to varying degrees

• it is important to note: all human languages are incredibly complex


 
page 92 language system of communication using sounds or gestures put together in meaningful ways according to a set of rules
• Language permeates everything we do

• It is a central part of our lives
 
page 92 symbols sounds or gestures that stand for meanings among a group of people

• Language is a system of symbols by which we communicate

• every society depends on this symbolic system for mere, basic survival

• symbols are always invested with meaning

 
• the society invests the symbol with meaning

• Examples:

 
• colors have symbolic association (Death = black [or white])
 
• numbers have symbolic significance (numerology, #3, #7)  
• landmarks, areas, blocks in cities

• specific people—heroes, celebrities, criminals, nationalities

• arts (the arts itself is an entire symbolic universe)

Return to Top  
page 92 signal a sound or gesture that has a natural or self-evident meaning

• signals are a kind of symbol, but one that is not [initially] culturally invested with meaning

• Example:
 

• a teardrop is a signal that someone is sad, or happy
  • but the English word crying is a symbol in spoken form communicating the act


• Animals as well as humans participate in signaling

• Some animals seem to have a rudimentary usage of symbolic language communication as well

 
• bees

• dolphins, whales, etc.

• other apes

• vervet monkeys
 

• but humans have developed the most complex language system by far  
• the physical structure of our head enables us to communicate better, while at the same time creating a greater chance for choking to death or for having impacted teeth

• understanding animal communication may help in the future to unravel some of the mysteries of fundamental language acquisition and development

Return to Top

The Nature of Language (93-97)

• no language has more than 50 sounds

• over 6,000 existing human languages today

 
page 93 linguistics the modern scientific study of all aspects of language

• scholars in India over 2,000 years ago studied the basics of language

• Age of Discovery in Europe stimulated research into language by bringing so many new languages to Western light

• 19th century's contribution:

 
• discovering the system inherent in language

• formulating laws and principles

• creating the science of linguistics (at that time called philology)

Return to Top

THE SOUND AND SHAPE OF LANGUAGE (94-97)

 
Phonology (94-95)
 
• In order to test the principles, laws, the theories, basic scientific processes must be used and tested

• Sound itself is the basic element in language formation, so the particulars of its creation must be understood in a scientific, testable way


 
page 94 phonetics the study of the production, transmission, and reception of speech sounds

  • Phonetics is the systematic study of sound  
• absolutely necessary to understand the fundamentals of language

• involves many different parts


 
NOT IN HAVILAND phonology the study of the sound patterns of language

  • Phonology is the study of the patterns of the sounds  
• need to inventory all of the sounds of the language

• reveals the underlying rules

• reveals what is permissible in the society


• First: need to inventory sounds, or utterances by isolating the smallest classes of sound that seem to make a difference in meaning

 
• these are the phonemes
Return to Top  
page 94 phonemes in linguistics, the smallest classes of sound that makes a difference in meaning

  Example: The minimal pair test  
• bit and pit sound the same except for one sound difference

• the b sound and the p sounds make a meaning difference in English for this word

 
• thus, b and p represent distinct English language phonemes

• they thus require distinct symbols to represent them in recording the language


• butter and budder might sound different but mean the same thing to a native listener

 
• they would thus not be separate phonemes  
• precisely because the meaning is the same


• they would represent alternative allophones of the same phoneme

 
• because they communicate the same meaning

• but do so using different pronunciations

Return to Top  
Morphology (95)

  • A very long task to make and study an inventory of sounds

• At the same time, a catalogue of all groups of sounds that have meaning is constructed

 
• these are morphemes

 
page 95 morphemes in linguistics, the smallest units of sound that carry a meaning

  • morphemes are the smallest unit of sound having meaning

• in contrast: phonemes have no meaning by themselves

 
• their sounds, however, affect meaning


• words can be morphemes: cat or dog is each a morpheme

• utterances can be morphemes: a grunt, an uh-huh or uh-oh means
 

• this is something specific [called vocal segregates; we will get to that on p. 101]

 
page 95 bound morpheme a sound that can occur in a language only in combination with other sounds, as s in English does to signify the plural

  • s depends upon another word to fulfill its plural connotation

• s cannot signify plurality without being attached

• thus, s is called a bound morpheme


 
page 95 free morpheme morphemes that can occur unattached in a language; for example, dog and cat are free morphemes in English

  • other morphemes can occur without being attached to other sounds  
• such as words (cat, dog, etc.)


• thus, they are called free morphemes

Return to Top  
Grammar and Syntax (96-97)

  • After identifying the sounds (phonemes) and meaningful units (morphemes), you have to understand how they fit together into a meaningful framework

• One way to begin is to use frame substitution


 
page 96  frame substitution a method used to identify the syntactic units of language. For example, a category called nouns may be established as anything that will fit the substitution frame "I see a [ ].'

  • by extensively using frame substitution, you begin to see how sounds and meanings are put together to form a language, a communicative model
 
page 96 syntax in linguistics, the rules or principles of phrase and sentence making

  • the system of rules and principles implementing any one case is called the syntax

• specifically invoked for piecing together morphemes


 
page 96 grammar the entire formal structure of a language consisting of all observations about the morphemes and syntax

  • the system of rules and principles organizing all of this is grammar

• basically, all of the morphemes, syntax, and form classes of the language


 
page 96 form classes the parts of speech or categories of words that work the same way in any sentence

  • think of form classes as parts of speech, such as nouns, verbs, etc.

• you can have different subcategories: such as animate and inanimate nouns (cat vs. house)


 
NOT IN HAVILAND descriptive linguistics the study of language concerned with registering and explaining all the features of a language at one point in history

  • all of this, upon study, is what you call descriptive linguistics

• Haviland: its main strength is its relative objectivity in method

 
• that the linguist can obtain a cultural distance from the material

• that the linguist will not assume nouns and verbs or other categories native to his/her own language

• is this true?

Return to Top

The Gesture-Call System(97-101)


 

Kinesics (98-100)


 
page 98 kinesics a system of notating and analyzing postures, facial expressions, and body motions that convey messages

  • Also known as body language

• a system of communication through motion

• typically the motions supplement verbal communication

• the study has come into its own since the 1950s

• Examples

 
• men and women: cross legs differently, hold arms differently in Western society

• Worldwide greetings: smile and shake head--in Bali, Europe, Samoa, Africa (!Kung), some South American Indians

 
• includes raising of eyebrows if you are really friendly

• in Japan, the "eyebrow flash" is suppressed, seen as indecent


• Yes and no can differ kinesically worldwide as well

Return to Top

Paralanguage (100-101)

 
page 100 paralanguage the extralinguistic noises that accompany language, such as crying or laughing

  • always accompany verbal language

• includes voice qualities, vocalizations, gestures, facial expressions, proxemics


 

Voice Qualities (100-101)

  • This is the 1st kind of paralinguistic noise: background characteristics of the particular voice
 
page 105 voice qualities in paralanguage, the background characteristics of a speaker’s voice

• these are the qualities that are characteristic of the particular speaker

• closely related to the personality of the speaker

• can indicate a general attitude or worldview of the speaker
 

• whether they are typically optimistic or pessimistic

• whether they are characteristically snobby or accepting

• whether they are generally active or lackadaisical

• whether they have a passive or an active approach to life

• etc.

 
Return to Top Certain features of voice quality may include: • pitch • low to high • lip control • closed to open • glottis control • sharp to smooth transitions in pitch • articulation control • forceful or relaxed speech • rhythm control • smooth to jerky • resonance • vibrant to thin • tempo • fast to slow  

Vocalizations (101)

 
page 101 vocalizations identifiable paralinguistic noises turned on and off at perceivable and relatively short intervals

  • This is the 2nd kind of paralinguistic noise: situational alteration of noise

• The speaker has control over these sounds

Return to Top  
page 101 vocal characterizers in paralanguage, sound productions such as laughing or crying that humans "speak through"

  • sounds indicative of an attitude
• laughing

• crying

• belching

• yawning

• yelling

• whispering

• usually indicate an emotion of some sort  
page 101 vocal qualifiers in paralanguage, sound productions of brief duration that modify utterances in terms of intensity

  • should be understood as modifiersof the utterance  
• high or low pitch

• loud vs. soft

• drawl or clip

 
• typically applied only to a single sound
Return to Top
• similar to voice qualities, except where vocal qualities are qualities of the entire voice, vocal characterizers are applied to short sequences of sound to impart tonal, pitched, or other meaning conveyed by sound
• Example: sharply telling someone to GET OUT!  
• that is a vocal qualifier, because a person would use it infrequently and only to impart a specific meaning in a specific situation


• However, a Southern drawl would be a voice quality, because a person would inflect all his language in the same drawl

 
page 101 vocal segregates in paralanguage, sound productions that are similar to the sounds of language, but do not appear in sequences that can be properly be called words

  • not real words, but more than phonemes
  • examples: shh, uh-uh, uh-huh
Vocalizations can completely change or enhance the explicit meaning of a sentence  
Example:  
• I am really happy with the grade I made on this test.
Return to Top

Linguistic Change (aka, Historical Linguistics) (101-106)


  • historical linguistics: the study of relationships between earlier and later forms of a language, antecedents in older languages of developments in modern languages, and relationships among older languages  
• it is the counterpart to descriptive linguistics, which covers all of the material we have talked about up until now

• where descriptive linguistics, studies language in its current usage, historical linguistics studies it in its historical contexts


• Language needs to be understood diachronically (over the course of time) as well as synchronically (whatever is true of language at one point in time)

 
• Thus we have historical linguistics

 
page 102 language family a group of languages ultimately descended from a single ancestral language

• English is Indo-European, and in the Germanic subgroup

Return to Top  
page 102 linguistic divergence the development of different languages from a single ancestral language

• linguistic divergence is a way of assessing historical divisions or mergers of peoples over time

 
• you see when languages break off or assimilate


• English was heavily influenced by the Norman invasion in 1066 and has a bunch of Old French influence (and thus, Latin)

 
• but this was primarily relegated to the upper or ruling classes, so that the more high-faluting words tend to have that Latinate background

 
page 103 glottochronology in linguistics, a method of dating divergence in branches of language families

• not important to know for the test
 
 
page 103 core vocabulary in language, pronouns, lower numerals, and names for body parts and natural objects

• what is centrally important in understanding a language historically is the core vocabulary

• this is the language that is central to understanding basic things and activities in a people's life

 
• pronouns

• lower numerals

• body parts

• natural objects

• basic social functions


• core vocabulary also refers to the important language central to a specialized group

 
• the military

• a profession

• an age group

Return to Top  
page 103  linguistic nationalism the attempt by ethnic minorities, and even countries, to proclaim independence by purging their languages of foreign terms or reviving unused languages

• both repression of language groups and revival of lost or almost lost groups
 

 
ANTHROPOLOGY APPLIED:  (on pp. 104)
LANGUAGE RENEWAL AMONG THE NORTHERN UTES

LEARN THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS STUDY IN ANTHROPOLOGY

UNDERSTAND WHY THIS STUDY IS PLACED UNDER THIS SECTION


1. What was the nature of the language renewal?

2. Who is William Leap and what did he do to assist in this process?

3. Why was language renewal seen as important to the tribal council in 1984?

4. What were the results of the renewal? cultural results? practical results?

Return to Top

Language in its Cultural Settings (106-112)

 

LANGUAGE AND THOUGHT (106-108)

 
page 106 ethnolinguistics the study of the relation between language and culture

• Ethnolinguistics is a core field in relating how people's thought relate to their actions

 
• that is, it is central to cognitive anthropology

 
page 106
Sapir-Whorf hypothesis
             or
Linguistic relativity
the hypothesis, proposed by linguist B. L. Whorf, that states that language, by providing habitual grooves of expression, predisposes people to see the world in a certain way and thus guides their thinking and behavior

• language not only encodes our ideas

• it also shapes our ideas, simply through the process of our encoding our thoughts into the symbolic system that language is

 
• the English example of using the have verb in tandem with the to be verb  
• by making the verb of possession necessary to the verb of existence, creates a constant reinforcement of the idea that in order to exist, a person in Western, English-using society must have as well
Return to Top

Kinship Terms (108)

Kinship terms reveal the nature and extent of family relationships, responsibilities, etc.

Not all societies name their relatives the same way as Americans do

 
• some have different names for mother's sister than for father's sister, even though we call both aunt

• names of brothers or sisters in terms of birth order are sometimes distinguished

• cousins can be called differently, depending on how they are related

• LOTS of variation cross-culturally


LANGUAGE AND GENDER (108)

• Language has built into it a society's values, norms?as we have learned

• It makes sense that attitudes toward the different sexes in society according to their gender roles and expectations should be built into it too

 
• It always does!


• What are examples from American culture of adjectives that describe men and women

 
• aggressive  
• in business man=go-getter; woman=sleeps to the top
Return to Top

SOCIAL DIALECTS (109-112)

 
page 109 dialects varying forms of a language that reflect particular regions or social classes and that are similar enough to be mutually intelligible
 
page 109 sociolinguistics the study of the structure and use of language as it relates to its social setting

• Dialects form one area of study for sociolinguistics

• Dialects become distinctive languages at the point where the speakers of one are almost totally unable to understand the speakers of the other

   
ANTHROPOLOGY APPLIED:  (on p. 109-111)
THE GREAT EBONICS CONTROVERSY

LEARN THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS STUDY IN ANTHROPOLOGY

UNDERSTAND WHY THIS STUDY IS PLACED UNDER THIS SECTION



 
1. Is Ebonics a separate language? If so or if not, should it be taught as one separately from English in the school system?

2. What are the pros and the cons of such teaching?.

3. What are the specific positions of Leanne Hinton and Ron Kephart? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each position?

4. Which position do you agree with? Why? What is wrong with the alternate position?

   
• What do you think Haviland thinks about Ebonics?
Return to Top  
page 112 code switching the process of changing from one level of language to another

• People switch the way they speak all the time

 
• from a lecture to talking to friends at work to talking to friends at a bar to talking to my kids

• dependent on the group with which you are interacting and the social and cultural norms you are negotiating


Other Sociolinguistic Concerns

 
• Other interests of sociolinguistics  
• children's languages and word games

• structure of folktales and folk songs

• bilingualism and multilingualism

• pidgin and creole languages

• linguistic borrowings and innovations

• formulas of address and politeness

• secret languages

• magic languages

• myth


• the field duplicates interests in several fields

• provides an arena for cross-disciplinary discourse

Return to Top

The Origins of Language (112-115)

Ways to get at origins  
• better knowledge of primate brains

• new studies of primate communication

• studies on children's linguistic competence

• more human fossils tell us what ancient brains and vocal tracts were like

• better understanding of early hominid way of life
 
 
page 114 displacement the ability to refer to things and events removed in time and space


• Studies of primates have shown that they can learn language (esp. sign language)

• Critics have said that this may simply be reflex, that they do not really assign transferable meaning to the symbols

• However, monkeys and apes do possess a number of necessary capabilities for language

 
• categorization of experience

• perception of things in structural relationships

• abstraction of higher-order to lower-order categories on the basis of common traits despite obvious differences

• potential for making analogies

• ability to make propositions

• ability to act on propositions toward a goal

• they are capable of displacement, which is said to be a distinctively human trait

Return to Top • Hominids needed communication in order to survive harsh conditions  
• since Homo erectus was first hominid to move into seasonally maladaptive areas, it is probable that they possessed language  
• this was 700,000 years ago


• Scholars have dropped the search for a primitive language

 
• because all human language is highly developed, incredibly complex, and able to intimate an infinite amount of meanings  
• this is true even of so-called Stone Age peoples


• however, a growing interest and research into the relationship between physical gestures and spoken language has emerged

 
• for example  
• gestural communication, such as sign language, encompasses an entire syntax of its own (creates meaning by stringing together different form classes)?common to all apes

• early hominids probably developed a syntax of gestural communication (like all other apes do) prior to the development of their spoken language

• when they began walking upright and used their hands increasingly for tools and hunting equipment, they had an added need for spoken language



Return to A11 Page Go to Readings and Class Schedule Go to CourseInfo at mygateway.umsl.edu Return to Professor Wolford's Homepage Return to Top

created: February 04, 2001
previously revised: February 01, 2002
last revised: February 18, 2002