Search

Advanced Search


LIFESTYLECOLUMNSFORUMSNEWSLETTERSPERSONAL FINANCESEARCHSPECIAL REPORTSTOOLSVIDEO VIEWS
CONTACT USADVERTISINGMEDIA KITSPECIAL AD SECTIONSCONFERENCESPERMISSIONS/REPRINTSMARKETPLACE

OCTOBER 27, 2003     Editions: N. America | Europe | Asia | Edition Preference


NEWS ANALYSIS

The Hidden Costs of IT Outsourcing
While moving software development and tech support offshore is all the rage, many companies find the overall savings aren't that great


Keith Franklin, president of Empowered Software Solutions in Burr Ridge, Ill., loves offshore outsourcing. It means more work for his 40-person company. Just last year, ESS, which specializes in developing applications for Microsoft's .Net platform for Web services, earned $500,000 in revenues from fixing buggy software written in India. It took ESS five months to repair a glitch-filled application for a Web portal. Most pages on the site weren't connected, turning updating into a nightmare. Some code was missing.

The shoddy work didn't come cheap, either: The Indian outsourcer went $1 million overbudget. Franklin says he could have done the project for less than $900,000 -- right here in the U.S.

Indeed, offshoring -- sending work overseas -- isn't always all it's made out to be. Particularly with information technology, which can be a lot more complicated than moving traditional manufacturing operations overseas. IT quality is much more difficult to gauge, says Atul Vashistha, chairman and CEO of info-tech offshoring consultancy neoIT in San Ramon, Calif. And since IT is an integral part of every business process, it requires more communication and management.

Offshore IT outsourcing started to soar during the economic downturn. With their companies' sales squeezed and shareholders screaming bloody murder, many CEOs began mandating that some IT work be sent overseas. They were following the lead of big companies, including chipmaker Intel (INTC ) and software giant Microsoft (MSFT ), that already do considerable software development in India and Russia. With the trend gaining momentum, more than 40% of U.S. companies will develop software or test it, offer tech support, or provide storage functions overseas by 2004, according to market consultancy Gartner (see BW, 10/27/03, "All The World's A Call Center").

"DIRTY LITTLE SECRET."  On paper, it looks extremely attractive. A Russian programmer charges 80% less than an American. But when you parse it all out, the total cost of offshoring a given IT job is generally comparable to getting the work done domestically, says Tom Weakland, a partner at management consultancy DiamondCluster. It's just that few companies are aware of these real costs. "Most companies can't accurately measure their productivity and costs prior to and after outsourcing," says Weakland. "Most look just at wages."

A few companies have learned the lesson the hard way. A year ago, 100% of neoIT's business came from consulting companies wishing to go offshore. Today, about 25% to 30% of its business relates to fixing problems, says Vashistha. Most companies don't want to advertise the problems they've run into, of course. "It's a dirty little secret," says Michael Mah, managing partner at software consultancy QSM Associates, based in Pittsfield, Mass. "There could be more crashed projects in the next 6 to 12 months."

One weakness of moving support functions overseas is that it leaves no one on-site to help customers. Take publishing-software maker Quark. For the last year it has based its English-speaking tech-support staff -- people you call if your app keeps crashing -- in India. Kamar Aulakh, Quark's president, claims that the move hasn't affected service quality or caused any customers to flee. He says his support staff is able to resolve problems over the phone. But the trend leaves some customers worried.

Continued on next page>>  | 1 | 2





SPONSORED LINKS

WebEx - Web Conferencing Solutions
WebEx online meetings and web conferencing solutions: Meet colleagues online, host web events, train your staff, provide live support. Join a live, online demonstration.

Ironmail - Email Security Appliance
Ironmail is the world's first email security appliance. Designed to combat Spam & Viruses, IronMail offers the most support for security protocols. Infrastructure options include support for IMAP, LDAP, POP3, and variants of SMTP (like SMTPI and SMTPO).

Record Everything Your Employees Do On The Internet
Spector CNE records all your employees’ Internet activity, including chats, instant messages, emails (Exchange, Outlook, Hotmail, AOL email), web sites visited and keystrokes typed.

Automatically Back Up Email Servers; Laptops & PCs
Storactive LiveServ delivers continuous, zero-loss backup for Microsoft Exchange servers and performs rapid recovery of emails on up to entire data stores. Storactive LiveBackup provides automatic backup and recovery for PCs & laptops. Free trial!

Intranet Connections: Enterprise Intranet Software
Corporate intranet software with 21 built-in applications, content management, role-based security, point-and-click design and customization options, friendly and easy to use.

Buy a link now!



Executive Book Summaries
Receive 8-page summaries of the most popular business books

e-prints and reprints
Buy an e-print or reprint for any BW magazine or online article.

New BusinessWeek Digital Edition - Get instant, electronic delivery of this week's newsstand issue or back issues in an easy-to-read format

Real-Time Quotes
For a nominal monthly fee, you can now get real-time quotes.

Investor Workshops
BusinessWeek's new investor education course.

Tech Business White Papers Directory
A complete index of white papers to assist in your company's decisions

Subscribe to Outlook Online
The Outlook is a unique advisory service from Standard & Poor's.

S&P Advisor Insight INVESTOR RELATIONS departments for companies in the S&P 500, S&P 600 and S&P 400.

BusinessWeek TV

BusinessWeek Online: Handheld Edition

BW Conferences




Back to Top



Take this survey - you can get 6 free issues of the top futures and options magazine

Has the equity market decline made you more interested in alternative investments such as Single Stock Futures?

Much more interested
Somewhat more
Somewhat less
Not at all

 




SPONSORED LINKS

WebEx - Web Conferencing Solutions
WebEx online meetings and web conferencing solutions: Meet colleagues online, host web events, train your staff, provide live support. Join a live, online demonstration.

Ironmail - Email Security Appliance
Ironmail is the world's first email security appliance. Designed to combat Spam & Viruses, IronMail offers the most support for security protocols. Infrastructure options include support for IMAP, LDAP, POP3, and variants of SMTP (like SMTPI and SMTPO).

Record Everything Your Employees Do On The Internet
Spector CNE records all your employees’ Internet activity, including chats, instant messages, emails (Exchange, Outlook, Hotmail, AOL email), web sites visited and keystrokes typed.

Automatically Back Up Email Servers; Laptops & PCs
Storactive LiveServ delivers continuous, zero-loss backup for Microsoft Exchange servers and performs rapid recovery of emails on up to entire data stores. Storactive LiveBackup provides automatic backup and recovery for PCs & laptops. Free trial!

Intranet Connections: Enterprise Intranet Software
Corporate intranet software with 21 built-in applications, content management, role-based security, point-and-click design and customization options, friendly and easy to use.

Buy a link now!



Executive Book Summaries
Receive 8-page summaries of the most popular business books

e-prints and reprints
Buy an e-print or reprint for any BW magazine or online article.

New BusinessWeek Digital Edition - Get instant, electronic delivery of this week's newsstand issue or back issues in an easy-to-read format

Real-Time Quotes
For a nominal monthly fee, you can now get real-time quotes.

Investor Workshops
BusinessWeek's new investor education course.

Tech Business White Papers Directory
A complete index of white papers to assist in your company's decisions

Subscribe to Outlook Online
The Outlook is a unique advisory service from Standard & Poor's.

S&P Advisor Insight INVESTOR RELATIONS departments for companies in the S&P 500, S&P 600 and S&P 400.

BusinessWeek TV

BusinessWeek Online: Handheld Edition

BW Conferences