Notes from
Chapter 5:
Society and
Technological Change, 3rd ed.
Rudi Volti
The
ideas and examples referenced below are notes compiled by Robert Keel and Shannon
Mayer in their reading of Volti's, Society and Technological Change,
3rd ed., St. Martin's Press, 1995. They are intended for classroom
use.
THE DIFFUSION
OF TECHNOLOGY
How are Technologies
adopted by individuals and organizations that actually put them into use?
The International
Diffusion of Technology
- Myth— Technology is
largely result of one’s own people --> Technological Nativism
- No Technologically dynamic
nation is autonomous from Technologies of other nations
- 1500's— China produced
most Technology
- 1500-1700's— Europe leads
world in Technological advances
- Yet many of these Technologies
were the continuation of earlier advances in technology from China and elsewhere
- United States— heavily
dependent on Technologies of other countries since its inception
- Even advances that originated
in U.S. are often owed to immigrants
- Bakelite-
(Leo
Baekeland- Belgium)
- Television Camera-
(Vladimir Zworykin-
Russia, see "oral
history")
- Sharing of Technology
isn’t as simple as merely transplanting Technology from place to place
- Technology is a system-
many components required to make it work, resources vary from country
to country
- Technology needs support
of human beings who understand its workings
- This may vary from country
to country
"A
country (or an individual firm) that draws on technologies developed elsewhere
is spared the expense of ‘reinventing the wheel.’ But making effective use
of imported technologies— even if only direct copying is required— often requires
a stock of indigenous skill that cannot always be easily found."
- Technologies shared between
countries can be used for very different purposes
- China— Gun
Powder— used medicinally for centuries— passed on to Europe
- Europe— within short
time using it for cannons and firearms
- When Technology is transferred
from one country to another, modifications are most likely required for Technology
to work.... Thus it isn’t the exact same Technology
- Japan and Steel Production—
Japanese tried to apply Dutch steel production but
- Had to make many
modifications. In particular, the special characteristics
- Of Japanese coal
and iron ore required special modifications
HOWEVER
The assumption that Technologies of developed nations are essential to economic
and Technological modernization of undeveloped countries is problematic
- Not all countries have
equal resources (human and material)
- Even if Technologies
can be transferred the results are not always desirable
- Pakistan— introduction
of tractor— replaces worker— 40% unemployment rate
- Workers migrate to cities—
dire poverty results— per acre crop yields hardly increased at all.
Equal use of
Technologies can have devastating impact
- U.S. (pop. 290 million)--
one car/ 1.5 people
- China (pop. 1.5 billion)--
one car/ 500 people
Could
we afford to equalize resources w/out resource and environmental breakdown???
- Technology of one country
may not makes good economic sense for another country
- Poorer countries need
Technologies that create human jobs, not replace human jobs
- Technologies are often
chosen by small power groups that represent their interests rather than the
interests of the country.
Technology cannot be
developed strictly for economic motives: values and morality of culture play
key role (Appropriate Technology)
Selection of Technology
reflects larger issues— social and political, as well as economic
Business Firms and Technological
Diffusion
- Diffusion similar to
that which occurs from country to country
- Factors that influence
diffusion:
- Relative advantages
over existing Technology
- Compatibility w/
existing values of firm
- Ease/difficulty of
understanding and applying new Technology
- Ease of experimentation
with new Technology
- Extent to which positive
results appear
- People with knowledge
of Technology are KEY to diffusion of Technology
- As with countries, Technology
that works in one environment may fail in another
Economics Motives and
Technological Transfer
- Expectation of cost and
benefits strongly influences speed at which Technology is diffused
- Mechanical
Reaper— pre reaper— grain harvested manually— LABOR INTENSIVE
- Mechanical Reaper introduced
(1830's) but diffused very slowly until 1850's
- 1850's--Crimean War—
increase of grain prices— motivation to produce grain
- More grain— bigger farms—
Mechanical reaper makes sense to buy
- Qualifications for Mechanical
Reaper— may not have been widely used because it required refinement in order
to be of practical use to farmer
Economic motive is
important BUT it is still only a presumption of the likely success of a
Technology
The "Not Invented
Here" (NIH) Syndrome
- Risky nature of Technological
innovation blocks the diffusion of new Technologies
- "The status quo
is a hell of a lot easier than making changes." Henry Ford
Efforts to
Restrict the Diffusion of Technology
"The exclusive possession of a particular Technology can
confer great advantages on those that have it."
- Venice— 16 cent. Glass
makers— assassins sent out to kill expatriate glass makers
- England— 1719— illegal
for skilled artisans to emigrate
- Present Day— strict rules
against exporting technologies
- Despite regulations,
diffusion of technology difficult to regulate
Patents
and the Diffusion of Technology
- Patents confer exclusive
use of an invention and are, obviously, highly desired
- Patents can stifle Technological
development
- Patents can help diffuse
Technological knowledge— patent makes public the knowledge
- Ideally, patents make
invention known and available to public rather that just inventor
- Patent isn’t an iron-clad
protection, merely a "license to sue"
- Patents often quickly
out-moded by Technological advance
- Advantages/disadvantages
of patent difficult weigh over the other
Questions:
-
What
makes particular societies better able to adopt and disseminate the technologies
of other countries (example: Japan)?
-
What
might be problematic about technology assistance programs created by advanced
technological societies in order to "assist" lesser developed
societies?
-
What
are the pros and cons of the patent system? What else could be done to preserve
individual interests and promote technological diffusion?

Chapter 15
Chapter 6
