Jack Stenner was UMSL's first ever All-American, earning those honors in the 1968-69 season. He was a member of the team that year, along with fellow inductee Greg Daust, that won the District 16 Championship and advanced to the NAIA National Tournament in 1969, the team's first appearance in a National Championship Tournament.

Stenner ranks seventh in UMSL history with 1,267 career points and second best career scoring average at 20.1 points per game. He was drafted by the Carolina Cougars in the ABA Draft after his career at UMSL.